Shareholder Rights

[Mark Bentley]

The table below show what services the major investment platforms offer clients for information and voting rights on their holdings.

Platform Name:	Can you ask the platform to notify you of upcoming general meetings for your shareholdings, or does the platform do this anyway?	Is there a charge for this service?	Can you ask the platform to automatically send you electronic copies of annual and interim reports, and circulars for your shareholdings?	Is there a charge for this service?	Can you ask the platform to automatically send you paper copies of annual and interim reports, and circulars for your shareholdings?	Is there a charge for this service?	Can you instruct the platform to vote on resolutions put to general meetings on your behalf?	Is there a charge for this service?	If voting is offered, is this through a simple electronic form, or is it more cumbersome to do so, e.g. by having to send a message with detailed voting instructions?	Will the platform issue letters of representation so that you can attend, speak and vote at general meetings?	Does the platform provide a standard electronic mechanism for requesting LoRs, or do specific messages have to be sent?	Is there a charge for providing a LoR?
AJ Bell YouInvest	no – sometimes   notified	no	no	na	no	na	yes	no	Unless   you wish to vote for all resolutions in the same manner, a message has to be   sent.	yes	a   message must be sent	no
Hargreaves Lansdown	no	na	no	no	no	no	yes	no	send an email -but it works   fine. And for capital raises etc, there is a specific form to be filled out   with detailed explanation	Yes, and they are (now) quite   efficient about it	in the email system, it is one   of the dropdown choices	no charge
HSBC	no	na	no	na	no	na	Don’t know	Don’t know		no	no	na
IG stockbrokers (direct client)	no	na	no	na	no	na	yes,   with difficulty	no	message   and begging	yes	no	£100
i-dealing	no	na	no	na	no	na	no	na		no	no	na
Interactive Brokers	no	na	no	na	no	na	no	na		no	no	na
Interactive Investors	yes	no	yes	no	no	no	yes	no	electronic   form	yes	yes,   standard mechanism	no
Natwest Stockbrokers	no	na	no	na	no	na	by   special request only	possibly	special   request	yes	no   – special request	possibly
The Share Centre	not reliably	no	no	na	yes	no	yes	no	electronic   form	yes	yes   – but may not cover AIM companies	no

[Mike Dennis]

Thanks Mark
The table looks good but the text is hard to read on the headers. Is it poss to change the contrast by lightening the background or making the text white rather than black.
Thanks
Mike

[Mark Bentley]

Hi Mike,

I’ve improved the backgrouond colour for the header row.

Best,
Mark

[Patrick Childs]

Thanks Mark, this table is brilliant.

This is Patrick from Leicester Square Signet. I have been with Share Centre. They have been very good at getting the registrars to send paper copies of annual reports etc. I even recently received the massive offer document for Shaftesbury’s open offer.
As you know they are being taken over by Interactive. The information I received was that interactive do not provide this service, although your table indicates that they do. Do you have any updated information?

I will try to get them on the telephone, although this is increasingly difficult. Paper copies of contract notes would be good, although I dont’ think they do this either. You get an email after about 48 hours telling you to log in to the website to download your contract note. To me that is very “clunky”. I would like to be looked after with a more automatic follow up.

Finally do you know the details of what section of the Companies Act the information rights are set out in?

[Mark Bentley]

In reply to reply #15622

Hi Patrick,

ii used to provide this service, but sadly it appears that they no longer do. I will update the table accordingly.

Part 9 of the Companies Act contains the provisions that enable (but do not require) nominee operators to nominate persons to receive information rights.

See this article for the latest on ShareSoc’s efforts to address these issues.

Best,
Mark

---

[Patrick Childs]

In reply to reply #15719

Mark
Many thanks for getting back to me on the Reports issue.

Actually I was told on Friday that they do still offer this service. I had to speak to a person while trying to deal in a foreign stock and he told me how to opt into paper communications. In fact he said that he had changed the option for me, also including paper contract notes.
I am waiting to see if I receive any material following the stated change. . . .
Unfortunately I cannot remember where on the website he directed me to to achieve this.

Patrick

---

[Cliff Weight]

The Telegraph wrote a useful article about AGMs and voting. see https://www.telegraph.co.uk/investing/shares/use-broker-hold-investments-account/

It was headed

How to use your broker to hold your investments to account

But the real story was in the byline – Stockbrokers require investors to jump through lots of hoops to register their vote.

It also explained the problems and quoted ShareSoc:

However, new investors might not know that owning company shares comes with part ownership of a company – and with it the right to vote on issues at their annual general meetings, or AGMs. 

Investors can make their voice heard on far-ranging topics, from how much company leadership gets paid, to whether it pays a dividend or donates to a political party.    

But fewer than 1pc of people actually take up their votes, according to ShareSoc, a non-profit organisation which represents the interests of shareholders in Britain.

Cliff Weight, of ShareSoc, said this was due to stockbrokers making it challenging for DIY investors to use their vote. Each broker has a different process for submitting votes.

The Telegraph article also included its guide on how to navigate the different broker processes.

[Robin Powell]

Hi, like Patrick, I enjoyed the excellent customer service provided by Sharecentre for many years. Unfortunately, ii service does not match up – due I suspect to the enormous influx of new customers from Sharecentre and elsewhere. I am currently doing battle with ii customer service over the provision of physical Annual and interim reports. I was led to believe they did facilitate them but now I am told they do not. Why is it that ii platform cannot provide this most important of services ? Because of the virus situation I have not yet broached the issuance of proxy letters to enable me to attend AGM’s. Any advice/assistance that members could offer would be appreciated. Regards, Robin Powell

[Mark Bentley]

Hi Robin,

Regarding Letters of Representation, ii are very good with this. Under account > personal details & preferences > your account information, make sure to subscribe to the “voting and information service”. You will then be able to vote electronically and/request to attend a meeting in person. When a meeting is announced, you will then receive a message advising you about it and directing you to your “voting mailbox”. From there you can submit your vote or press a button to request attendance. If you press the button, a letter of representation will be sent to you automatically, after you’ve completed personal details.

Best,
Mark

[Cliff Weight]

Ii have changed their system re letters of representation and you now need to complete more information, most of which they already hold about you. It is irritating when “progress” makes things more difficult. Did they do this deliberately (conspiracy) or by accident (poor management or cock up!)?

[Patrick Childs]

We are a very select group on this forum! I am rather sorry to see that and wonder how we could gather more momentum.
I am also an Ii investor and had my concerns about the takeover by the appalling ABRDN. But I believe that the founder is still involved in the management, can’t remember his name.
The whole UK quoted company system seems to be creaking with no-one wanting to buy the shares – or at any rate not enough people. In the case of individuals that will be because the FCA has more or less banned anyone who might give advice from doing so. Why is that?
They have also forced companies to put so much information into Annual Reports that you cannot find what you want. And then consultants add a lot of useless presentation guff. And the report is too big to keep. Read it online, they say.
AT the recent Shaftesbury (property) AGM I asked why they had not included any detail of acquisitions and disposals in the report. In fact I asked where it was in the report. The answer was that it wasn’t there. It was in the RSN’s (someone please correct me if that’s not the right expression) they had put out during the year. Ok, but how can they think that such information does not also belong in the report?

[Author]

Posts